Link to top Back of the Envelope

Blog
Writings About Me Photos
Links

Friday, July 29, 2005

The conventional wisdom...
... is that the conventional wisdom is always wrong. Discuss.
Opposites attract?
Scott Kirwin is singing the praises of Liberal-Conservative marriages over at Dean's World:
There are serious benefits to a Liberal/Conservative marriage. First and foremost it keeps both of us from the extremes. If she comes home with some barking moonbat piece of tripe, I can usually shoot it down before she has wasted too much time on it or worse, come to believe it herself. Likewise I can sound an idea or an opinion off her and get her candid take on it before going public with it - thereby applying a level of rigor to what might otherwise have been a stupid idea or opinion. Secondly we can intellectually spar with one another, thereby keeping our ideas fresh and perhaps even (gasp) changing them. Finally, when we're together we can handle issues and situations using our different perspectives. Because of her liberal nature she can be much more open with salesmen than I can be. If the salesman takes advanatage of her openness, I can step in and bitch-slap him into submission without any regard for his feelings or the validity of his opinions. Needless to say the "Good cop - Bad cop" routine comes in quite handy when dealing with disputes with retailers and service providers.

I don't see opposites attracting as a good foundation for a relationship, but I do think there is a need for complementary personalities. If the members of the couple are too different, then they find themselves in conflict with each other, while if they're too similar, then they don't need each other. It's when one's strengths can cover the other's weaknesses, and vice versa, that they work best together. While marriage is the most obvious example of this, there should be some degree of this in every team.

Thursday, July 28, 2005

The Trinity, Part III: Son of God
A week or two ago I received this question in a comment to one of my old posts about the Trinity:
Weren't Hebrew prophets like David referred to as the "son of God" in the Hebrew Bible?

The implication, of course, is that the Bible calling Jesus the "Son of God" is no different from how others were referred to. I have some thoughts on the matter, but I'd like to hear your opinions before I share them.

New Post: My answer is now here.
Who's afraid of "foreign" religions?
I know you guys don't really need me to find Instapundit, but I found one comment by Glenn really interesting. After quoting an article discussing how Christian missionaries have been successful at converting Muslims in Indonesia, Glenn says of Christianity's appeal: "Plus there's the lack of exhortations to suicide bombing, which many probably see as a plus. Those 'more moderate' leaders might want to work with that."

The moderate Muslims of Indonesia are helping their government oppose the Islamofascists, but in return, they want the government to stop missionaries from converting Muslims. I know that Christians and Muslims take a different view on these matters, and the fact that I'm an American Christian probably colors my view even further, but I believe that all views should be able to compete in the marketplace of ideas, even religious beliefs. Of course, I can say this with confidence since Christianity has a history of growing best where it must compete with other faiths and worldviews. But I would no more want to forcefully prevent a Christian from converting to Islam than to stop a Muslim from converting to Christianity. Whenever I hear of Christians converting to Islam, my first thought is to wonder whether they were coerced, as happens in many parts of the world. My second thought is that they probably were not that committed to Christianity in the first place. Many, many Christians are what we call culturally Christian--raised that way, calling themselves that, but not really committed. Not all, but I would guess most, Christians who convert to other religions were cultural Christians. They had no real relationship to Christ (what being a Christian is all about) to begin with. While I don't want to see them moving even further away, I believe that moving from effective materialism with a coating of nominal Christianity to a worldview that takes spiritual matters seriously is actually a step closer for many of them, and there is hope that they will come full circle and find the Christianity they missed growing up. For my part, I will do my best to convince them, but I'll do that by argument and persuasion, not by protecting them from hearing alternative worldviews.

I imagine that the mirror image to this is happening in Indonesia: cultural Muslims finding in Christianity a vibrant spiritual life they had missed before. If these moderate Muslim leaders are at all confident of their religion, they should expect that they can hold onto believers, and win back those they have lost, by persuasion in the open marketplace of religious beliefs.

Wednesday, July 27, 2005

Those Left Behind, Chapter 3 of Fire
The Rest of the Story: Appears here on this blog, but you can read all 17 chapters (plus the prologue and the interlude) here.

Rather than coming up with a new story, I'm simply posting the next chapter of Fire here. Wait! Come back!

Chapter 3 is one of my unexpected chapters--it happened because events I set in motion in Chapter 2 had waylaid my initial plans. Nevertheless, I like how it turned out. Don't even think about reading this chapter before you read the first few chapters (linked to above), as it will not make sense otherwise. That said, enjoy!


Chapter 3
Those Left Behind


Lucia’s elbow slipped from the arm of her chair, jerking her awake. Worried that someone might have noticed her lapse, she sat up straight and tried to look alert. Her father was with the same client with whom he had been speaking when she lost track, so she must not have missed much. He had not noticed her dozing, and she sensed that the other clients either had not seen or were pretending that they had not. Glad that she had not harmed her dignity too much, Lucia tried to concentrate on her father’s words. Marcus Principius had honored her with access to his morning audience, and falling asleep in the middle of it would make her a child again in the eyes of her father and of his clients. She tried to drum up the enthusiasm she had felt last month. Lucia had begun attending the audience at the insistence of her mother and her Philosopher tutor. For years she had longed to join her father at his morning sessions, just like the succession of older brothers who had stood by his side. A Patrician’s sons were expected to take part in his counsels, and it was considered a sign of trust for his wife to sit in on them, but daughters never joined him. Lucia’s mother had little use for the audience, however, and she was more than happy to give Lucia her position. Though Novar tradition did not consider the wife’s rightful role transferable, Marcus Principius allowed his daughter to sit in her mother’s place.

The Heir Apparent himself stood, of course. Among the Novar, while men might recline for informal occasions, sitting in a chair bestowed a dignity necessary only for the official functions of magistrates or priests. Marcus Principius held neither office at this time, and he would have deemed it inappropriate to sit for this audience even if he did. The majority of patrons felt the same. Most Patricians and some of the more powerful Plebeians had clients who depended upon their financial support and political protection. These clients would visit their patron each morning, either to request his help, repay debts, or simply to remind him of their existence. Many were freedmen, former slaves from his household, with their poor woolen tunics and customary conical caps. Some were wealthy merchants, citizens who wore their togas and probably had more wealth than their patron, but who needed his political backing to do their business unobstructed. Most were somewhere in between. From poor country farmers to well-to-do craftsmen to struggling poets, the more important the patron, the larger and more diverse the crowd which called on him.

The number of people calling on Marcus Principius had increased over the last few years, as it became clearer that he and his family would become the Imperial heirs. The numbers had begun to overflow the atrium where he received them. At the center of this room was a pool kept filled by rainwater entering through a small hole in the roof. A large mosaic of a storm at sea, complete with an overhead view of ships caught far from shore, surrounded the pool. The storm continued up the wall in paintings of expansive sea and sky, pierced by lightning strokes which illuminated a distant shore. The ceiling’s mosaic completed the effect with a dark, cloud-covered sky, with just a hint of the sun right where the hole in the roof let real sunlight in. Little illumination came through this early in the morning, so oil lamps in the corners of the room provided light for the scribe recording the day’s session. These lamps did little to keep the late winter chill at bay in the large atrium, and the small braziers scattered around the room weren’t much better. Doors on the east and west side of the atrium led to small rooms inhabited by the slaves of the house. At the north of the room, large wings on either side, called alae, held busts of Principius ancestors and a small shrine to the household gods. Even if religious custom did not mark the alae as off-limits to the crowd, the additional room still would not be enough for all of Marcus’s clients, so a continuous stream of them entered and left the atrium through the large entranceway to the south.

One client, a young writer with dark hair and beautiful brown eyes, smiled at Lucia. Her return smile trembled a bit. The young poet may have acted shy, but the hunger she sensed in him frightened her. She used to enjoy flirting more than anyone. Even though she knew that she would never marry for anything as pure as love, Lucia had always been eager to meet new people. Now she was much more cautious of people’s motivations because she was much more aware of them. Unnaturally aware of them, she thought, since Victor’s disappearance. Despite their dissimilar personalities, she and her brother had been very close, and their personalities had always complemented one another rather than conflicted. She could always draw him out of his shell, and he could add some forethought to her enthusiasm. Now that he was gone, not only did she feel the loss of part of herself, she worried that something else was trying to fill that void.

Lucia and Victor could always tell what the other was feeling, sometimes even what the other was thinking. Now in that part of her where she should have sensed Victor, she could sometimes sense others. She watched her father’s current solicitor, and although they were speaking too low for her to hear, she could tell that he was lying. She could also measure her father’s skepticism--good for him--though he was giving his client the benefit of the doubt for now. She wished she could still believe that she imagined this awareness of hers.

She closed her eyes, trying to shut out her sense of the others in the room, but that made them even clearer. She could count the number of people in the atrium without opening her eyes. Two more were coming in now, a wealthy merchant followed by his slave. Lucia kept her eyes closed. Someone else entered close behind them, but where she could identify the others, what followed was a blank. The Dominus! Her eyes snapped open, and sure enough, the Dominus had just entered. The merchant stepped out of his way even more quickly than his slave.

This same Dominus had been visiting almost every day since Lucia had begun to attend her father’s morning audience. She felt certain that he came to see her. When he had first appeared, she had wished with all her might that he would go away, certain that he was the Dominus responsible for her brother’s disappearance. Lucia had another trick, an ability more frightening than her sudden awareness of people: sometimes, when she really wanted someone to do something, he would. The trick worked about as reliably as a sundial on a cloudy day. In the case of the Dominus, she had only sensed a sudden alarm from him and then nothing at all. From then on, all she could sense of him was a moving hole in the crowd. She knew he was there, but she could not tell anything about what he was thinking. Lucia couldn’t read minds, just receive impressions about people, a sense of their state of mind, and she couldn’t get even that much from the black-robed monster.

The Dominus took position near her, watching carefully. Not watching her father, who was finally talking to another client and doing his best to ignore the Dominus, but her. She tried to ignore him as well as her father did, wondering whether the man could read her mind. He stood there in his long black robes, face hidden by his hood, and stared at her.

Marcus Principius had offered his financial support to the struggling young poet, and he now turned to look at the Dominus. The Dominus returned his gaze. Lucia still could sense nothing from the Dominus, but she felt a wave of tangled emotions coming from her father. She expected the anger, fear, and grief considering Victor, but she could not understand the sense of familiarity and even affection. Her father spoke, “The audience is at an end for today; any further business will have to wait until tomorrow. If you have something urgent, please talk to Gerol.” The scribe, sitting on a stool behind a nearby table scattered with ink, styluses, parchment, and waxed wooden tablets, bowed his head in acknowledgment. He was a pale and wizened older freedman whose conical cap hid an unruly mass of white hair. Lucia did not need any special senses to read his mind. His face clearly showed his annoyance at having to sort those with truly urgent problems from everyone else, who only thought their problems were urgent.

There arose some muttered complaint that the session had ended half-an-hour early, and eyes darted to the Dominus as the likely cause of the interruption. He ignored them, which unnerved people more than if he had stared them down, and the muttering died quickly. Lucia’s father drew her from her chair and, placing an arm around her, led her from the atrium into the more private areas of the house. The Dominus watched but did not follow.

Her father’s comforting arm around her shoulders did not alleviate the distance between them. Marcus Principius knew something about what had happened to Victor and about the Dominus who had taken him, something that he kept from the rest of the family. They all suspected this, but with her awareness, Lucia knew that her father grieved Victor less than the rest of them did and that he was hiding some secret that she could not puzzle out. A division had opened up between him and his family. Only Lucia’s certainty of her father’s love for their family allowed her to tolerate his close-mouthedness. Her mother had no such certainty.

Marcus Principius walked her to his library, where her tutor was waiting. Marjori’s graying hair was pulled back and tied in a bun, which gave her a severe look and made her appear older than her few wrinkles warranted. She wore a gray robe with two bands of light blue at the hem, the mark of her School of Philosophy. Marjori looked up from the scroll she had been reading, sparing Lucia’s father little more than a glance as her pupil took her place at the table across from her instructor. Marcus Principius recognized a dismissal when he saw one, so he slipped out and left his daughter to face Marjori alone.

Marcus was proud of his library, which dwarfed most private reading rooms. One wall contained hundreds of pigeonholes, each holding a single scroll. Scrolls were fading in popularity, but the Principii had a number of old works. They also had many sealed wax tablets, used mostly for contracts, stacked on shelves along another wall. Bound books, each containing hundreds of sheets of paper, filled the remaining shelf space. Marjori insisted on the efficiency of this method of binding, and given another hundred years, she thought the backwards Novari would catch up with the Philosophers and discard the more traditional ways. Lucia sat on a stool behind the large oak table that dominated the center of the room. Her instructor stood.

“Did you complete the assignment that I gave you last night?” she wanted to know.

“Uh, almost,” Lucia said. She wished she could read Marjori as easily as she could read other people. The Philosopher kept most of her emotions well-buried, though she made no effort to hide her disappointment now.

“Very well, then, let’s see the work you did complete.”

“I... uh... meant that I almost did it,” Lucia admitted. She hated disappointing anyone, especially now that she could feel it so sharply, but lying would not help her with Marjori. “I didn’t actually get to it.”

“Indeed.” Lucia had thought Marjori’s disappointment could not get any worse. “Need I remind you that your father has gone to a great deal of trouble, not to mention the expense of my own considerable fees, to make sure that you and your brothers have had the best education in the Novar Empire? He would be most unhappy to discover that you have been squandering it.” She sighed. “Tell me, what did you do yesterday?”

“Well, I went to the baths yesterday afternoon--”

“And doubtless you went there to gossip rather than to take advantage of the libraries. I don’t think that would have consumed your whole evening.”

“Yeah, but I met Livia there--”

“Which Livia? You have three friends named Livia, and you know at least two others.”

“This was Livia Ameliana. She invited me to her home for dinner. You see, her brother was home from the army--”

“And she wanted to play matchmaker,” Marjori sighed. For once, Lucia sensed something other than disappointment from her. Was it pity? Neither her tone nor her expression reflected it. “I would have thought by now you’d have given up on that. You are of the Imperial Family, Lucia. You--”

“But--”

“Don’t interrupt me, young lady. As I was saying, your marriage will be decided based on political alliance. Chances are your husband won’t be Publius Amelianus.”

“But if it is--”

“Then you’ll recognize him at the wedding.” She gave Lucia a very direct stare. “I’d recommend that you not attempt to ‘fall in love’ with anyone.”

Anger won out over her desire to please her tutor; Lucia didn’t think she had much chance of doing that anyway. “Do you even believe in love?”

“It depends on what you mean by ‘believe in.’ Yes, there is certainly such a thing as physical attraction, emotional attachment, even passion. One day you’ll realize that these things are greatly overrated. They come and go with a whim, and have as much weight. In time, they fade altogether.” Lucia received a very quick, very strong impression of pain underlying those words. It made her feel dizzy for the moment before it passed. “Trust me, political alliance is a much stronger foundation on which to build a lifelong relationship.”

Lucia pushed aside the temptation to ask her about the pain. Aside from the awkwardness of asking about something she should know nothing about, she was not eager to experience it again. She had never dreamt that her ability could hurt her in any way. Instead, she headed for a safer subject, “Then what do you believe in?”

“I am a Philosopher, Lucia. You should know what that means. I do not believe in any such nonsense as gods, superstition, or magic. The only thing I put my faith in is Knowledge.”

Lucia knew she had chosen safe ground. Marjori could go on for hours about the faith of the Philosophers. She made no secret of the fact that she wanted to convert the entire Principius family to a faith which Lucia’s father called the strongest belief in nothing he had ever seen. “I myself am a Philosopher of Books. I collect, organize, categorize, and disseminate information. Many outsiders look at my profession as the least of the Philosophical Schools, but I assure you that it is among the most important. Discoveries and innovations do no good if no one learns of them. Seekers of knowledge are much better off with my help to direct their searching. I...”

Lucia was considering trying for another nap when she really heard something Marjori had said earlier. “Wait a minute. Did you say that you don’t believe in magic?”

It took Marjori a moment to notice the interruption. Lucia could feel the sudden shift in attention. “What? Oh, yes, of course I don’t believe in magic.”

“But... what about the Domini? Everyone knows that they have power.” Lucia knew for a fact that this was more than rumor.

“The Domini? I will confess that they have power, too much for their own good. The way everyone lives in fear of them gives them a great deal of influence over people. That is what allows them to simply take anyone--” She cut off suddenly, and Lucia detected a mixture of regret, anger, and grief. And pain, nearly as strong as before. Lucia knew that Marjori missed Victor, who had always been her favorite pupil, but she detected more to this than Victor’s disappearance. “Let me just say that I have never seen them do anything supernatural.”

“Wow, you really don’t believe they have any magic, do you?”

“Maybe they possess some abilities I’d consider unusual. That doesn’t mean that I’d call them magical. Personally, though, I suspect that their power comes more from fear and superstition than from anything truly unnatural.” Lucia could tell that however much Marjori wanted to believe those words, she had not fully convinced herself.

“Do the Domini take boys from the Philosophers as well?” Lucia asked, surprised that the question had even left her lips.

The pain returned, sharper than ever. Lucia had to fight off tears whose cause she didn’t know. She wasn’t certain how Marjori could retain her composure. Indeed, Marjori’s eyes tightened to reflect the pain now, and though nothing else in her expression followed suit, her response had an unusual edge to it. “Yes.” Lucia could hear the cry of grief and frustration that word should have been. Marjori took a deep breath, and spoke with a calmness she could not possibly have felt. “Not all the Philosophers feel as I do.”

Her voice took on a lecturing tone, “As you should know, while the Philosophers are recognized as a nation by most of the other states, we do not consider ourselves as one. We are a community of people who share a distinct set of beliefs and a common purpose: to learn. Thus the center of our island ‘nation’ is the University. All who participate in the University, either as students, teachers, or researchers, are Philosophers. Unlike other nations, no one can be born a Philosopher. Many at the University have come from other nations to dedicate themselves to the Philosophy. The University educates children of Philosophers until they reach the age where they can decide for themselves whether they wish to follow the path of their parents. If so, they become Philosophers, otherwise they lose the support of our community. At this point, most leave, although they may join the community of non-Philosophers which provides needed services to the University.” Marjori had used this lecture as a chance to bury her feelings, and to prepare herself to say something without dredging up the emotions so tightly bound to it. “When boys reach the age where they must decide whether or not to follow the Philosophy, the Domini take the ones they want.” They had taken someone close to her. Lucia was certain of it, though she could not say whether she had reached that conclusion by simple reasoning or with some unnatural help. “We do not oppose them.” The last came with difficulty, and Lucia could feel her fighting back emotions she was unwilling to face.

“As interesting as this discussion has been, we have work to do. If I am to teach you even the rudiments of true mathematics, we should get started.” With her emotions under control, Marjori’s voice picked up strength as she warmed to a new, safe topic. Except for her usual intensity when teaching a subject she considered essential, Lucia could detect nothing else. Perhaps, this time, getting to work was a good idea.



Aside from the short break she’d had to eat some bread and fruit for lunch, Lucia had been working all day at deciphering the strange symbols the Philosophers used as numbers. Her fingers ached from their grip on her stylus, painfully writing out the odd numerals. When Marjori had first begun to teach her Philosopher mathematics, Lucia had protested at the uselessness of learning a system of numbers completely different from the Novar one. She had later found the Philosopher system easier to work with for anything more complex than addition. That had not made her more amenable to the strange numerals, since she wasn’t convinced that she’d ever want to do anything more complex than addition. In any case, she had been staring at the foreign symbols for so long that her vision was beginning to swim. A glance out the window looking onto the peristylium showed that it must be the third hour past noon by now.

“Getting a little impatient, Lucia?” Marjori asked, noticing her longing looks towards the lifeless garden. “I had hoped to explain the basics of algebra today, but, as usual, I was overambitious.” Despite her harsh words, Lucia did not detect any real disappointment. “I’d give you something to get done by tomorrow, but I don’t expect you’d do it, would you?”

“Tomorrow’s a festival day. There will be chariot races all day.”

Marjori gave an exasperated sigh. “Never mind, then. Go, I’m sure you’ll meet one of your friends at the baths today. Maybe another Livia.”

“Bye, Marjori.”

“Farewell, Lucia.”

At that, Lucia put down her stylus and abandoned the wax tablets filled with her clumsy version of Philosopher numerals. She hurried out of the room before Marjori could change her mind. A quick walk through the sunlit peristylium brought her to her own room, where her attendant Jaelin was waiting for her. Jaelin helped her out of her red dress with its black trim and into a simple white tunic. Aside from the color and length, the tunic differed little from the dress. Neither bore any resemblance to the complicated clothing worn by women in Manuel. That style had never caught on in Novaro, despite its popularity in other parts of the Empire. While her mother found Manuelite style ludicrous, Lucia wondered how she herself might look in some of those dresses.

Jaelin, Lucia’s slave girl, was several years older than she. She had the height and coloring of what had once been the independent northern tribes, with freckles scattered across her fair skin, and fiery red hair for which Lucia occasionally felt some envy. Though she hid it quite well, Jaelin hated the life of a slave. If the girl had not genuinely liked her mistress, Lucia would have found her constant but concealed bitterness difficult to endure. Jaelin wore a rough grey tunic similar in shape but not quality to Lucia’s own.

Escorted by two large, well-armed slaves, Lucia and her companion made their way to the baths. The narrow streets they travelled were as crowded as anyplace else in Novaro. Palaces abutted shops which pressed against tenements which more often than not leaned on warehouses. This made for crowded, noisy streets where rich and poor alike fought to make headway among hawkers and open-air merchants. The tall buildings with their overhanging balconies kept the streets in shadow, lowering both the temperature and the safety of the people below. Their guards assured that they themselves were not troubled in their short walk to the Imperial baths.

The baths themselves were a marvel, constructed by one of the lesser-known and lesser-liked emperors in an attempt to find immortality. That attempt had not succeeded, as none of the customers remembered the official name of the facility, instead calling it the Imperial baths. Admission was a mere pittance, and that would have been a bargain even if it had been ten times as much. Constructed mostly of marble, the structure was part library, part performance hall, and part gymnasium. Once inside the outer wall, men and women both mingled in the outer courtyard, still clothed of course, where each enjoyed watching the exercise of the other. The libraries were located here as well, built into the surrounding wall, and struggling poets read their work to any audience who would listen in the recitation rooms. In the center stood the baths themselves, with separate facilities for men and women. Whether for the exercise, the bathing, the poetry, or the gossip, everyone went to the baths.

Lucia joined a group of girls her own age, including not one but two friends named Livia, in trying to keep a metal hoop upright and rolling using hooked poles. This game had no real point aside from not letting the hoop fall. This was in sharp contrast to the highly competitive sports the boys played, usually with balls that stung if they hit you. The game left her sweaty and dusty, but she enjoyed the playing as much as she enjoyed being watched. The latter had become less fun recently. She much preferred imagining what the men were feeling to actually knowing it. Sometimes she found their emotions disturbing, especially those of the older men. A few of them made her feel like prey, and it was not just her. Those regarded just about any youth, male or female, the same way. Lucia avoided them as well as she could, sometimes passing this advice along to others.

She had just decided that it was time to take advantage of the baths themselves when she noticed her brother lurking in the shade of one of the walls. Aulus considered the public baths with all their attractions a waste of time. He kept himself fastidiously clean, but he preferred any bathing he did to be at home, and he did not enjoy athletics of any sort. His mere presence should have been enough to stun her, but it seemed unimportant next to the man with whom he was speaking. Lucia had never seen the man before, and the cold-blooded ruthlessness which imbued him made her fervently wish that she would never see him again. It surprised Lucia to receive such a strong impression at her first contact with him.

He was regarding Aulus now, and Lucia knew he was contemplating something terrible. Then Aulus noticed her. He and the strange man exchanged a few more words before the stranger moved away. Aulus leaned against the wall, waiting for her to approach. She looked for the stranger again, but he had vanished. Only then did she realize that she could not remember a single physical detail. He had seemed so ordinary that Lucia thought that she could meet him again and not even recognize his face. She would recognize his presence, though, and she could never mistake that. She decided she should talk to Aulus, calling “Hey!”

He smiled wryly at her call, annoyed and trying not to let it show. “Hello, Lucia. Imagine meeting you here.”

“I’m here everyday. I think you’re the one out-of-place.”

“So? I think I have as much right to be here as anyone else.”

“That’s not what I meant. It’s just that you don’t usually come to the baths.”

“I’d thought I’d see if anything had changed since the last time I was here.” He leaned forward and lowered his voice. “Besides, it’s a great place to get to know important people. You know, make a few contacts.” That was true enough, and Lucia did not sense any lie in it. She might have left it at that, if she had not seen, and felt, the strange man.

“Is that whom you were talking to, someone important?”

Aulus was instantly on his guard, but doing a good job of not showing it. “Who, him? I have no idea who that was. He was new to the city and just wanted directions to the Temple of Minerva.” It surprised Lucia how easily Aulus could lie to her. Even with what she had seen, she might have believed him except for her ability: she knew he was lying. Before she could say anything more, Aulus pushed himself from the wall. “If you’ll excuse me, I have to go look for some of those important people.”

She stood watching his back as he headed towards the men’s baths. She had begun to shiver in the late winter sunlight, the warmth from her exercise fading and leaving her chilled and damp with sweat. Aulus knew how to make her angry enough to leave him alone, but it would not work this time. “Aulus!” she called out. Annoyed, he turned to look at her. “Be careful, he’s dangerous.”

Lucia felt suspicion, shock, and anger chase through Aulus’s mind in a moment. He looked around to see if someone had overheard. Those emotions vanished quickly, and after looking at her with something which was unnervingly considering, he answered her, “I know. And don’t worry, I’ll be careful.”

She watched him go, then headed towards the women’s baths. Jaelin, who had been playing dice with their escorts, joined her at the door, carrying her toiletries and clean clothes. Lucia wished she had someone to talk to about Aulus’s strange behavior, and the Dominus, and... well, the other thing. She wanted Victor back more than anything else. He was the one person she’d been able to trust with everything. She barely noticed as tears mingled with sweat on her cheeks.



Lucia woke to the sound of Victor’s voice, a cry for help filled with desperate fear. She rolled out of her bed immediately and headed out the door. She had not bothered to pull on anything warmer than the tunic she had worn to bed, and it was cold in the night air of the peristylium. The first frost, if it came tonight, would kill the flowers Avla had worked hard to keep thriving despite the autumn, but Lucia did not concern herself with the flowers as her bare feet tore up their share of them.

She reached the door to Victor’s room and tried to pull it open. Their bedrooms didn’t even have locks, but the door wouldn’t so much as rattle on its hinges. She pounded on it, but that felt like hitting brick and made less sound. Her mouth opened to call out when the door suddenly shivered and swung outward, forcing her to step back. She saw Victor, lying on his back in midair, arms and legs dangling toward the ground as his body floated headfirst through the doorway. A Dominus trailed behind him. Lucia stared, open-mouthed, her impulse to scream forgotten at this fantastic sight. Her shock gave the Dominus the time he needed. He made no motion that she could see, spoke no word aloud. If he so much as mouthed an incantation, she couldn’t make it out. Some sort of spell was cast, though. Her head filled with a strange ringing sound, and in a moment darkness followed.

Lucia’s breath was coming in sharp, ragged gasps as she came to full wakefulness. She sat up in her bed, hugging her knees to her chest. Again! How many times had she had that dream? She couldn’t remember, but it used to happen every night, sometimes more than once. Several months had passed, but she was still calling it an improvement when the dream came only one night in three. The first time she had awoken like this, the night of Victor’s disappearance, real mud had stained her feet. She had hurried to his room to discover her brother truly gone. That was still true now, even if this recurrence had only been a dream. Putting her head on her knees, Lucia cried herself to sleep.


This chapter is 5,260 words long, out of a 90,111 word novel. So far, I've posted 17,227 on this blog. This is also, I believe, the first chapter I ever wrote with a female POV. I'm not sure whether the fact that Lucia's a young, naive teenager made it easier or harder.

Tuesday, July 26, 2005

The subway shooting
Most conservatives have defended the London police for the accidental shooting death of a Brazilian man. The situation is described in the news:
Menezes was killed in a London subway station as police investigated a wave of botched bombings the day before and the deadly transit bombings of July 7.

Witnesses said Menezes was wearing a heavy, padded coat when plainclothes police chased him into a subway car, pinned him to the ground and shot him dead.

While Menezes' relatives said he was working legally in Britain and had no reason to fear police, the British Broadcasting Corp. said Menezes' visa had expired, suggesting a reason for why he ran.

It's pretty easy to see both sides of the story, actually. From the police perspective, they had been monitoring the house, the man was dressed in suspiciously bulky clothing, and he refused to stop when ordered. But the Brazilian was accosted by plain clothes policemen, and depending on his grasp of English language, he may not have understood who they were or what they wanted, which is the point that Mark Steyn makes in his column:
With that in mind, we turn to Jean Charles de Menezes, the supposed "suicide bomber" who turned out to be a Brazilian electrician on his way to work. Unfortunately, by the time the Metropolitan Police figured that out, they'd put five bullets in his head. We're told we shouldn't second-guess split-second decisions that have to be made under great stress by those on the scene, which would be a more persuasive argument if the British constabulary didn't spend so much time doing exactly that to homeowners who make the mistake of defending themselves against violent criminals. And, if summary extrajudicial execution was so urgent, why did the surveillance team let him take a bus ride before eventually cornering him in the Tube?
...
We at this newspaper are currently defending British soldiers facing prosecution for situations broadly analogous to those in which the Met found themselves. But there's still a difference. Anyone who rubs up against the military in Iraq knows what to expect: attempt to crash a roadblock and don't be surprised if they open fire. But few of us had an inkling of the Met's new "shoot to kill" policy until they shot and killed Mr de Menezes. And although I've had a ton of e-mails pointing out various sinister aspects of his behaviour - he was wearing a heavy coat! he refused to stop! - it seems to me there are an awful lot of people on the Tube who might easily find themselves in Mr de Menezes's position.

I happened to be passing through London on Friday. It didn't feel terribly warm, but I spend half a year up to my neck in snow so when it climbs to a balmy 48 I start wearing T-shirts. But I can understand why a Brazilian might find 61 and overcast no reason to eschew a heavy jacket. So a man in a suspiciously warm coat refuses to stop for the police. Well, they were a plain-clothes unit - ie, a gang - and confronted by unidentified men brandishing weapons in south London I'd scram, too.

This is one of those difficult situations. While Mark refers to the passive culture which the British have put in effect as the problem, I don't see that a more aggressive culture would have avoided this situation. Perhaps police who were more accustomed to being armed and facing a possibly armed opponent would have dealt with it better, perhaps not. This is best seen as a friendly-fire incident, something which is regrettable, and incidents of which can hopefully be reduced in the future, but which are not entirely avoidable in a time of war. And make no mistake, this is a time of war. It has been declared on us, and it is better to be fighting it than to be passively losing it.

Related Posts (on one page):

  1. The subway shooting
  2. More Bombings
  3. Bombings in London Again
So, what am I writing now?
Well, I've finished that fanfic I told you about. Actually, I just finished the rough draft, but as fanfics are less involved than my usual stories, it doesn't require quite the usual number of revisions. So what do I plan on writing next?

To be honest, I'm not sure. I really want to get back to Fire's sequel. I keep saying I will, but I keep gettting distracted. Meanwhile I'm concerned about the Storyblogging Carnival. I don't have anything in the works that can go up in time for this next one, so you'll probably get something old. And if I'm going to make real progress on Fire's sequel, I may need to continue using old stories as Storyblogging Carnival entries while I work on that.

Well, you'll find out what I do soon.

Monday, July 25, 2005

More Bombings
There were more bombings at the end of last week which got less news than the previous ones, both in Egypt and in Lebanon. From Fox News, on the Egyptian bombing:
The bombers who carried out Egypt's worst-ever terrorist attack appear to have entered this Red Sea resort in pickup trucks loaded with explosives that were hidden under vegetables, security officials said Sunday. Police were searching for three suspects believed to have survived the bombings.

One truck headed for the luxury Ghazala Gardens (search) hotel. There, one man planted a bomb in a suitcase in a parking lot, while another slammed the vehicle into the Ghazala hotel's reception area, the security officials said, speaking on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the investigation.

As people fled the Ghazala attack, the suitcase exploded and killed at least seven people, said the officials.

A second truck, on a road leading to another major hotel, got stuck in traffic in the Old Market — an area frequented by Egyptian workers in the resort area on the southern tip of the Sinai Peninsula. Two militants inside abandoned the vehicle, apparently setting a timer, and the blast detonated soon after, the officials said.

With an estimated 88 dead, more were killed than in the London attacks, but it's getting a whole lot less press. Egypt's been struck with terrorist attacks before, most recently last October. There are some indications of al Qaeda ties with this latest attack, although it's not certain. The Lebanese attack has no clear link to al Qaeda, and in fact seems to be just the latest in the string of attacks on the anti-Syrian government. These are most likely the work of Hez'bollah, which has long had the support of Syria.

Having said that, the multiple London attacks and the one in Egypt may be part of a larger movement by al Qaeda to strike at the West and its allies with a wave of bombings. This sort of thing is easier to orchestrate than the 9/11 hijackings, and I would be surprised if they were unable to use similar methods to strike at the US. Sustained terrorism is more likely to wear us down than the large, dramatic attacks, and while I hope we can prevent them, I doubt our ability to. The solution remains getting to the root of the problem, and showing that terrorism will only increase our determination, not reduce it.
Now accepting submissions for Storyblogging Carnival XXIV
I will be hosting the Twenty-fourth Storyblogging Carnival on August 1st. If you're not familiar with the Storyblogging Carnival, storyblogging is simply story-telling in blog format, and the carnival collects examples of it submitted by anyone who wants to participate. If you have a story on your blog that you'd like to submit to the Carnival, please e-mail me at dscrank-at-alum.mit.edu (or post in my comments), including the following information:
  • Name of your blog
  • URL of your blog
  • Title of the story
  • URL for the blog entry where the story is posted
  • (OPTIONAL) Author's name
  • (OPTIONAL) A suggested rating for adult content (G, PG, PG-13, R)
  • A word count
  • A short blurb describing the story

The post may be of any age, from a week old to years old. The submission deadline is 11:59 PM Eastern time on Saturday, July 30th. More detailed information follows:
  1. The story or excerpt submitted must be posted on-line as a blog entry, and while fiction is preferred, non-fiction storytelling is acceptable.
  2. The story can be any length, but the Carnival will list them in order of length, from shortest to longest, and include a word count for each one.
  3. You may either send a complete story, a story in progress, or a lengthy excerpt. By lengthy excerpt, I mean that it should be a significant portion of the story, at least 10% of the whole thing. You should indicate the word count for both the excerpt and the complete story in the submission, and you should say how the reader can find more of the story in the post itself.
  4. If the story spans multiple posts, each post should contain a link to the beginning of the story, and a link to the next post. You may submit the whole story, the first post, or, if you've previously submitted earlier posts to the Carnival, the next post which you have not submitted. Please indicate the length of the entire story, as well as the portion which you are submitting.
  5. The host has sole discretion to decide whether the story will be included or not, or whether to indicate that the story has pornographic or graphically violent content. The ratings for the story will be decided by the host. I expect I'll be pretty lenient on that sort of thing, but I have some limits, and others may draw the line elsewhere. Aside from noting potentially offensive content, while I may say nice things about stories I like, I won't be panning anyone's work. I expect other hosts to be similarly polite.
  6. The story may be the blogger's own or posted with permission, but if it is not his own work he should gain permission from the author before submitting to the Carnival.

If you'd like to be added to the e-mail list, please let me know. Finally, I appreciate folks promoting the carnival on their own blogs, and I'm always looking for bloggers willing to host future carnivals.

Sunday, July 24, 2005

Weekly Webcomic Update
Sluggy Freelance — Zoe meets up with Frank and his daughter Meander, who've been trapped in the building since Frank was fired. Zoe convinces them to make a break to the lobby, but one of the bugs, having alreaday given a frog sentience, invades Frank. Has Frank been turned into a Zombgeek, or just made a little geeky? And what does Zoe have against cheerleaders?

Day by Day — This week, we've got the MSM, the NAACP, vibrating cell phones, conspiracy theorists, Ted Kennedy, and much more.

Scary Go Round — Shelley has jellyfish tow her Argentinian agent boyfriend to shore, Fallon gets herself killed for being a rogue agent, and Shelley helps deliver what looks like a clone of herself to Tackleford.

General Protection Fault — We begin by hearing Trevor's side. It looks bad, as Fred really has been nasty to him. Of course, that doesn't excuse Trevor trying to kill him.

Schlock Mercenary — The fleetmind has succeeded in neutralizing the threat to the galaxy, and they've declared war on the Paan'uri in Andromeda, without consulting their organic bosses. Meanwhile, future-Kevyn's retired, leaving Tagon and present-Kevyn to pick up the pieces.

Saturday, July 23, 2005

In defense of the Half-Blood Prince
I previously gave my quick review of the Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, being very vague in the attempt to avoid spoilers. Now I want to be very specific, and discuss the events near the end of the book, but in doing so I will be telling you precisely what happened, and quoting extensively from the book. If you don't want to know what happens, DON'T READ. I'm hiding the relevant text, which means that if you want to read it, you have to click the (show) link. Only do this if you want to know how the book ends.
...


Update: There's a nice discussion going on in the comments, no doubt due to all the visitors Google's sent my way, but be careful--there be spoilers there as well.

Related Posts (on one page):

  1. In defense of the Half-Blood Prince
  2. Review of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

Friday, July 22, 2005

That's got to be politically incorrect...
I mean, how could anyone possibly argue that gay marriage is a plot against homosexuals?

I don't really agree, as the reasoning doesn't completely work and I don't think homosexuality is purely genetic. (I believe that genetics influences personality, and personality influences sexuality, but I've never been one to think that there's no degree of decision-making in our sexual preference.)

Thursday, July 21, 2005

Bombings in London Again
Someone tried to hit London a second time, this time with three bombs in the subway and one in a bus, just like before. Is this a follow-up of the terrorist attacks, or a copy-cat at work. Either way, they were a lot less successful than before. From Fox News:
Metropolitan police are looking for an unknown number of fugitives connected to four explosions in London Thursday and are hoping the bombing material used can lead them to the terrorists.

Two weeks to the day after terrorist attacks in London killed a total of 56 people, explosions struck three more Underground trains and a bus at lunchtime Thursday.

Metropolitan Police commissioner Sir Ian Blair (search) confirmed that three explosions occurred on subway trains near the Oval and Warren Street stations on the Northern Line and on a train near the Shepherd's Bush station on the Hammersmith and City line, and that a fourth explosion took place on a bus traveling in the Hackney neighborhood of east London.

But none of the presumed bombs appeared to have detonated properly, leaving only one person injured. Officials were hoping that the leftover explosives would provide a wealth of forensic evidence to help investigators hunt down whoever planted them.

Of course, Fox does something here that I can't quite agree with. Compare it to this AP report:
Only one person was reported wounded, but the explosions during the lunch hour caused major disruption in the city and were hauntingly similar to the July 7 bombings in which 52 people and four suicide attackers were killed.

I'd probably say it differently, as while I also would want to make a distinction between the victims and the suicide bombers, I do admit that the bombers are people too: evil, twisted, fanatical people, but that does not put them outside the definition of personhood. Still, you've got to give the AP credit for making the distinction. Of course, it no longer reads that way:
Explosions struck three London Underground stations and a bus at midday Thursday in a chilling but less deadly replay of the suicide bombings that killed 56 people two weeks ago.

As I said, I'd call the terrorists people, but I would definitely make the distinction between the terrorists and their victims. To Fox's credit, they do do that later in the article:
Although not as serious, Thursday's incidents were hauntingly similar to the blasts two weeks ago, which involved explosions at three Underground stations simultaneously — quickly followed by a blast on a double-decker bus. Those bombings, during the morning rush hour, also occurred in the center of London, hitting the Underground railway from various directions. The four homicide bombers, along with 52 others, were killed in those attacks.

That, aside from the term "homicide bombers," which I've always disagreed with, is how I would say it.

Related Posts (on one page):

  1. The subway shooting
  2. More Bombings
  3. Bombings in London Again

Wednesday, July 20, 2005

On the nomination of John Roberts
It looks like a lot of conservatives are very happy with him, although I've been looking for but not finding evidence of public statements and judicial opinions that confirm that he's a solid conservative and originalist. Still, I do trust the opinions of the likes of John Hawkins, Hugh Hewitt, Captain Ed, the guys at Powerline, and the folks at National Review, so I won't argue that he's not a good choice.

I will say that I was discussing with a friend Bush's choice, and she asked me why Bush didn't choose a woman. I found this an odd question. As I put to her, Bush had a responsibility to choose the best candidate who reflected his judicial philosophy. He interviewed both men and women for this position, trying to find the person who met this requirement. Should he have only interviewed women? If the answer to that is "of course not," then how can we say that he should have picked a woman? Would he have just been going through the motions when he interviewed men, but not seriously considering them? If, in the course of those interviews, he found a man met his requirements better, it'd be downright irresponsible to pass over him for a woman just because she was a woman. And in all the reports I'm reading on the matter, it seems like everyone agrees that Roberts is probably THE most qualified person for this position in terms of legal credentials. In any case, Chermaine Yoest has a good article on why making O'Connor's seat the Woman's Chair on the court would be bad for women.

Tuesday, July 19, 2005

Review of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
So I read the latest Harry Potter book in one day--almost in one sitting--this Saturday. Was it any good? In a word, yes. J.K. Rowling's story took a darker turn somewhere around Book 3, and she's killed off a significant character in each of the last two books. This book is sufficiently dark and serious that I am very reluctant to call it a children's book. Admittedly, I haven't been calling Harry Potter a children's story since I started reading it. The characters may be children, but the subject matter they're facing is remarkably adult. By which I mean that they are dealing with life and death matters, not sexual ones.

The most important part of this book is the character development. There are the stirrings of serious romantic interest, which is interesting but fortunately does not dominate the book. It's a tad predictable who (probably) ends up with whom, anyway. Ron, Hermione, and Harry all grow a bit, but more interestingly, we get a great deal of insight into characters who are generally the antagonists, including Malfoy, Snape, and, of course, Voldemort. Speaking of these three, I'll admit that I've always had a soft spot for Snape. True, he is "evil," and he hates Harry with an unreasoning passion, but he's also very, very good at what he does, and you get the hint that there's more to him than meets the eye. You're never really sure whose side he's on. By the end of this one, it seems pretty clear who he's working for, but even so, I still have my doubts.

I won't tell you who the Half-Blood Prince of the title is, although I will say that I had guessed correctly pretty early on and held onto the hope that I was correct despite all the author's attempts to dissuade me. That my initial guess was right made me very happy.

Related Posts (on one page):

  1. In defense of the Half-Blood Prince
  2. Review of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
Storyblogging Carnival XXIII online
Doc Rampage has the latest Storyblogging Carnival up. If you're not familiar with the Storyblogging Carnival, storyblogging is simply story-telling in blog format, and may be as simple as posting short stories on a blog, or as involved as posting as a fictional persona. A carnival, in blog parlance, collects and organizes entries from numerous participants in a central location, and thus the Storyblogging Carnival collects examples of Storyblogging.

Monday, July 18, 2005

Mark Steyn sounds angry
I mean really, really angy:
The British suicide bombers and the Iranian nuke demands are genuine crises. The Valerie Plame game is a pseudo-crisis. If you want to talk about Niger or CIA reform, fine. But if you seriously think the only important aspect of a politically motivated narcissist kook's drive-thru intelligence mission to a critical part of the world is the precise sequence of events by which some White House guy came to mention the kook's wife to some reporter, then you've departed the real world and you're frolicking on the wilder shores of Planet Zongo.

What's this really about? It's not difficult. A big chunk of the American elites have decided there is no war; it's all a racket got up by Bush and Cheney. And, even if there is a war somewhere or other, wherever it is, it's not where Bush says it is. Iraq is a ''distraction'' from Afghanistan -- and, if there were no Iraq, Afghanistan would be a distraction from Niger, and Niger's a distraction from Valerie Plame's next photo shoot for Vanity Fair.

I think he's had just about enough of the Plame affair. Frankly, so have I, although I'm usually polite enough not to call people kooks. But no, I don't regard Wilson as a great patriot, and the information which the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence presented on his mission does not put him in a flattering light.

Sunday, July 17, 2005

Weekly Webcomic Update
Sluggy Freelance — The bugs the creepy cloner geeks were planning to use on Zoe, which are supposed to convert all her social skills to geek smarts, escape and attack the audience, thus changing everyone but Zoe into a zombgeek. Thus Pete shifts effortlessly into a 28 Days Later parody. Although I've never seen 28 Days Later, I'm really enjoying the humor, especially when the head cloner gets his just desserts.

Day by Day — A few Rove jokes, a bit about the Iraq flypaper strategy and the continuing debate on it, but mostly a lot of fun interactions of the principle characters.

Scary Go Round — Shelley's having a boring time on the Island of Armageddon with the League of Enemies, who act more like they're on a Carribean vacation than planning to take over the world. It improves when a spy shows up for the express purpose of killing the League, with just enough time beforehand to romance Shelley. Too bad Fallon comes along and kills him right before he gets to the "eliminating the League" part.

General Protection Fault — The case begins once the judge decides that, if both the defense and the prosecution concur that the slime mold is a person, he ought to go along with it. Opening arguments are made, and all that lawyerly stuff. The problem, as I see it, is that Fred doesn't exactly show the proper respect to the court, and it's liable to hurt his case.

Schlock Mercenary — The battle has begun, as the Fleetmind battles the Paan'uri, which is what the dark matter entities call themselves. Fortunately for Tagon, he wisely decides to leave the Serial Peacemaker shortly before Ennesby gets it destroyed. I'd guess that Ennesby himself will survive, but he's just lost most of his brainpower.

Saturday, July 16, 2005

Read now, blog later...
I had large plans for today. I was going to blog, get a haircut, clean my apartment, write that last chapter of the story I've been working on, play some Knights of the Old Republic II. That's all been interrupted due to the unexpected arrival of the new Harry Potter book from Amazon. I may get the weekly webcomic update done this weekend, but other than that, don't expect to hear from me until Monday.

Incidentally, I say "unexpected" because, while I pre-ordered it and knew it shipped yesterday, I used the free shipping, which takes an estimated five to nine days to arrive. Of course, I also knew that estimate was wrong. If you use Amazon and haven't at least tried the free shipping, you're wasting money. Your order needs to be at least $25--I combined the order for Harry Potter with one other book, which, because it was immediately available, shipped separately and arrived two days after it shipped. In fact, most things I order from Amazon using the free shipping only take 1-2 days to arrive, as fast as they promise for all but the most expensive shipping options. Of course, I benefit from living close to a distribution center (there's one in Springfield, MA, less than an hour and a half from here), so if it's in stock there it arrives in no time. Only when I order something that has to be delivered all the way from Nevada does it take anywhere near the estimated time to deliver, and I have a pretty good handle on what sort of items need to be shipped from there, so if I'm in a hurry I know what I need to upgrade the shipping option on. Your mileage may vary, of course, depending on how far away from one of their distribution centers you live, but give it a try... and use the Amazon button on my sidebar if you want to thank me for the suggestion.

Friday, July 15, 2005

Speaking of peer-reviewed papers...
You can tell an electrical engineering paper is really old when a picofarad capacitor is referred to as a "micromicrofarad condenser."
Doc and Dean on peer review
Doc is singing the praises of peer review, citing something Dean said earlier:
It's important that you understand the significance of that: a paper in a peeer-reviewed journal is not Gospel, but it is written by a respected researcher and, before it's published, it undergoes a lengthy process where other qualified researchers in the field review it carefully, point out possible flaws or objections, challenge his references, and give the author a chance to meet their objections and/or clarify his reasoning before publication.

In other words, while a peer-reviewed paper may be wrong about something, it is extraordinarily arrogant to think you can just skim it and toss off a casual dismissal. You need to respect the material, and that means that before you spout about it you read it carefully and think about it, under the assumption that someone who's quite smart and quite well-informed wrote it, and that other people who are quite smart and well-informed reviewed it before it got published.

To which Doc follows up: "Experts aren't always right, but they are always experts."

Now I've defended the peer-review process on this blog before, but I think Doc and Dean are overstating the case somewhat. I can't speak for political science, but in my Ph.D. field, you don't have to be "respected" to get a peer-reviewed paper published (although it helps), nor is the peer-review process necessarily lengthy. Generally only two or three reviewers will read the paper before it's published, and whether the reviewers really thoroughly examine the paper (or even read it themselves rather than have one of their Grad students do it) depends a lot on the reviewer. Now, the quality of the reviewer, and the attention he pays to the paper, largely depends on the quality of the journal it's submitted to and the perceived importance of the paper's results, so generally the more important papers are better reviewed. Also of note is that unless there's an obvious problem with the data, most reviewers will take your word on experimental results. I've never heard of a reviewer insist on an independent reproduction of experimental results before accepting a paper, but that's not surprising, as it would be impractical to do in most cases. This has led to problems in the past of "respected" researchers falsifying results for years before they were caught.

So am I saying that the peer-review process is useless? No, just that it's not only imperfect, but far less perfect than most laymen give it credit. At least in the field of experimental physics. Maybe it's different in computer science: that might explain why Doc accepted Dean's defense of peer-review so completely.

Thursday, July 14, 2005

A Stranger in the Library, Part II
Old Post: The first part of this story is here.

This is the second part of "A Stranger in the Library." I won't say much about it until you've read it.


A Stranger in the Library
Part II


The next day, Marjori arrived early only to find the Dominus already in the Library’s lower catacombs, his face uncovered while he examined the various books she had laid out the day before. He looked up sharply as she approached, and then, rather than relaxing when he recognized her, his shoulders tightened as he bent back to work. Marjori wondered whether he had seen her blush. She had no reason to redden over a mere dream, or even many dreams, enough to keep her awake most of the night. Why she should dream about this stranger rather than her fiancé was a mystery she thought best left to the Philosophers of the Mind. Rubbing the grit from her eyes and hoping the poor lighting hid the dark spots beneath, she went back to sorting through the haphazard heap of ancient texts.

When she came back with a few carefully selected books, he looked up just long enough to give a brief, disinterested thank you. Marjori decided not to put up with his surliness. “I’m sure you can be more gracious than that.”

“I said thank you. What else do you want, Philosopher?” He kept his eyes on his work.

“Well, for one, you could mean it. And you could call me by name. It’s Marjori, in case you’ve forgotten since yesterday. I’m certain I mentioned it then.”

He looked up finally. For some reason he seemed reluctant to meet her eyes. “Forgive me,... Marjori. I am unaccustomed to speaking casually with anyone outside the Order. Besides, I’m afraid I didn’t sleep well. Neither is any excuse for rudeness, however.” Now that he mentioned it, Marjori thought she could see dark spots under his eyes as well.

“Why couldn’t you sleep?” she asked, curious as to what had disturbed his sleep.

“I’d rather not talk about it,” he said. Softening his tone, he asked, “Is there anything else?”

“Yes there is. You could tell me your name.”

He did meet her eyes then, searching for something. After a long silence, he answered,

“My name is Aulus.”

During the next few days, Aulus did away with the intimidating manner typical of Domini and treated Marjori as an equal. That did not make him loquacious, as he still refused to answer most of her questions. He avoided inquiries into the rumored powers of the Domini, and when she asked him about the boys the Domini took, his intense brown eyes met hers as he said, “We don't murder children.” He refused to say anything else on the subject, and he also flat out refused to say anything more than his name about himself. The name Aulus was Novar, and Marjori thought she could hear a bit of the Novar accent in his voice, but the man would not comment on any connection between the Domini and the Novar Empire.

Aulus asked more questions than he answered, showing a particular interest in Marjori’s forthcoming marriage. She would have considered his questions impertinent coming from anyone else, but he asked with such open curiosity in his intent gaze that she found herself confiding even her unexpected misgivings.

“I’ve always known I would marry Ranius,” she told him as she sat across the table, her hand idly drawing in the table’s dust. “And I think that's what's bothering me. Philosophers don't believe in arranged marriages, but Ranius's parents and mine knew each other before we were born, and they saw us as a match before we did. We've been friends all our lives, and lovers for several years now. I'm not sure we've ever slowed down to ask whether this is what we really want.”

She felt Aulus's hand touch hers, brushing it before he pulled back. He gave her an uncertain half-smile. “Then what do you want?”

“I am a Philosopher, and I've never wanted anything else. Philosophers do the reasonable, sensible thing--the right thing. All I want is to get over these girlish jitters.”

Aulus gave her a more certain smile, one which she could have sworn looked relieved. “Then I'm sure you will. Everyone gets nervous just before their wedding.”

The dreams continued, and they did not help their work relationship. She often found her thoughts wandering while listening to him talk, wondering whether he was truly as passionate yet gentle as he was in her dreams. The wandering thoughts bothered her as much as the dreams themselves. She never lost focus, at least not when she could listen for secrets he might let slip while speaking of traveling from the Novar city Martia to the Sovereign City of Maro as if it were a walk across town rather than a journey between the furthest ends of the civilized world. Only lack of sleep could explain how she hardly noticed when he trailed off, watching her watch him. She couldn’t believe that something as silly as bizarre dreams tempted her. How could she even imagine a dalliance with a Dominus? Her engagement to Ranius was the least of the reasons why such an affair was wrong.

More than once, Marjori found herself comparing Aulus to Ranius. She had read that any woman compares every other man unfavorably with her beloved. That romantic notion might have been true for other women, but Marjori was a trained Philosopher. Objectivity had played as large a part in her education as history or mathematics, which meant Ranius did not always come out ahead. Both men pursued their studies with diligence and discipline, but Ranius was a Philosopher like her, and that had engendered a sort of distance in his work. He believed in its importance and he did it well, but he saw it as only a small contribution to a greater whole. The Philosophy was changing the world; he was just helping. Aulus, by contrast, worked as though the world depended on him. He would toss aside a book in frustration, only to dig out another and run through the pages with a determination she had never seen. The Philosophy taught that passion was a weakness, that only objectivity and distance could overcome problems, but Marjori wondered what it felt like to believe in one’s work the way Aulus did.

“What’s so important? What are you looking for here?” she asked again and again as he would pore over yet another book. It wasn’t until the fourth day that he gave in and answered that question.

Aulus leaned back in his chair, pushing away the heavy tome he had been reading, and met her gaze from where she sat across the table. “I shouldn’t tell you this. Before I do, I need your promise not to share it with anyone else.” He waited for her assent before continuing. “The Domini see themselves as humanity’s defenders, preserving knowledge that could save or destroy the world. I believe that it’s really fear that defines us. We cultivate it in others, thinking that if people fear us, we can control them. It’s for their own good, of course.” His voice dripped sarcasm. “When the time comes, we’ll be the only ones who can save them.” He shook his head. “I don’t know how many of us believe that anymore. Whatever we really think, we’ve succeeded in our endeavor. People do fear us, and distrust us, and hate us. If the disaster we dread does comes to pass, why should they look to us for help? Meanwhile, we’re bringing about our own extinction by turning humanity against us. We’re just too afraid to see it.”

“What are you afraid of?”

“The legends call them demons.”

“But the demons are just myths, aren’t they?”

Aulus sighed. “I believe they existed once. No one knows what they were, but the Domini do have another name for them: the Malwer. We know they were very powerful and very dangerous, but that’s no more than the legends say. My Order believes its purpose is to defend the world from them. We did so once, over a thousand years ago, but we don’t know how we defeated them or what became of them, and because we know so little, they terrify us, so we, in turn, terrify everyone else. That has to change, but it won’t until we’re no longer afraid.”

“So you’re looking for evidence that you don’t have to fear them anymore? Will that help?”

“I hope so. If I can prove to my Order that they’re gone, maybe we can end this doctrine of fear and become an open society like the Philosophers. We could share what we know and what we can do, allow people to come to us and learn rather than drive them away. But I haven’t found a thing. Just legends and myths, nothing more than what I already knew.”

“What do you know? It’s more than what’s here, isn’t it? These don’t even mention the Domini.” She gestured to the books. They credited the defeat of the demons to the First Legion and the Amaranthine.

Aulus grimaced. “They do, if you read between the lines. We weren’t the Domini then; we didn’t organize into the Order until centuries later. Before that time we were a fractious lot, small groups who didn’t speak to one another. It took the Amaranthine to unite us and help us imprison the Malwer, but then they made the mistake of leaving us with the responsibility to guard that prison. We no longer remember where that prison is or how to guard it, so my Order believes that we must prepare for the demons’ inevitable escape. I, on the other hand, think that if they still lived and could escape, they would have done so by now. I just need to prove it.”

“Look, if this doctrine of fear doesn’t work, shouldn’t that be enough? If you can show them that this strategy hurts them in the end, won’t that convince them?”

Aulus was shaking his head before she finished. “I’ve tried! You’d think that the logic of
it would bring them around, but it won’t. Their misguided beliefs are too ingrained--”

“Survival is even more ingrained. If your colleagues are as educated and intelligent as you, sooner or later they will have to see that.”

“What if they’re too stubborn to change? Our old influence is eroding away. While I know that we must adapt to what the world’s become, others insist on trying to reclaim past glories. The Order’s structure makes any change almost impossible, and the Domini just can’t see--”

“If your Order’s own traditions destroy it, perhaps it deserves to die.”

“Maybe it does,” Aulus said, and let his face fall into his hands. “That is what I am afraid of.” His hands muffled his words. Marjori wondered how she would react if she saw the Philosophy destroying itself. Did she care about it enough to oppose it? Rising from her chair, she cam